AP US Government · Supreme Court cases

Which required Supreme Court case most directly strengthened the national side of the federal-national balance described by Madison?

James Madison, Federalist No. 39, 1788

Madison argued that a republic derives its powers directly or indirectly from the people and places government offices in persons holding them for limited periods or during good behavior. He then described the proposed Constitution as neither wholly national nor wholly federal. Some features rested on the people as individuals, while others preserved the states as political units.

Adapted from James Madison, Federalist No. 39 (1788).
Which required Supreme Court case most directly strengthened the national side of the federal-national balance described by Madison?

Answer and explanation

Answer: D: McCulloch v. Maryland , by recognizing implied national powers and federal supremacy over conflicting state action

McCulloch v. Maryland upheld implied congressional power to create a national bank and held that a state could not tax it, strengthening national authority and federal supremacy, so D is correct. Choice A is tempting because Lopez is a major federalism case, but it limited Congress's Commerce Clause power, favoring the states. Choice B, Baker v. Carr, let federal courts hear apportionment challenges but did not establish implied national powers. Choice C, Shaw v. Reno, limits state redistricting on equal-protection grounds, not the scope of national legislative power.

More Supreme Court cases questions

All Supreme Court cases questions

Learn the method behind questions like this one

The AP US Government course teaches each tested skill through lessons, step-by-step solutions to sample problems, the complete study guide and full-length practice tests.